Dr. Rena Malik, urologist and pelvic surgeon, provides an in-depth, evidence-based discussion on the wide range of surgical options for benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH), or enlarged prostate. The episode covers minimally invasive procedures like Rezum, Urolift, iTind, Optilume, and Aquaablation, as well as traditional surgeries including TURP, laser therapies, enucleation techniques, and robotic simple prostatectomy. Dr. Malik examines the benefits and risks of each treatment, addresses the impact on sexual function and recovery, and shares guidance on how to choose the right option based on prostate size, anatomy, overall health, and personal preferences.
Surgical Options for BPH: What Every Patient Needs to Know
Are you waking up several times a night to urinate, or find yourself straining just to empty your bladder? Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH), commonly known as an enlarged prostate, affects millions of men worldwide—especially as they age. After 60, about half of all men will experience it, and that number climbs dramatically with each decade[1]. For many, urinary symptoms such as urgency, frequency, dribbling, and incomplete emptying can severely impact quality of life.
While lifestyle changes and medications can help, some men cannot tolerate these therapies or simply don't improve enough. When symptoms persist, surgical options become a necessary consideration. Here’s an expert, evidence-based overview of today’s treatments, their risks, benefits, and factors to weigh when making a decision[1].
When Is Surgery Needed?
Surgery for BPH is considered in several situations:
- Failure or intolerance to medication
- Absolute indications: recurrent urinary tract infections, persistent bleeding from the prostate, kidney problems due to urine backup, or the inability to urinate without a catheter[1].
Factors to Consider Before Surgery
The best procedure depends on several personal and medical factors:
Size and anatomy of your prostate
Overall health and ability to tolerate anesthesia
Current medication use (e.g., blood thinners)
Sexual side effects, particularly preservation of ejaculation
Tolerance for recovery time and risk of repeat procedures[1]
Overview of Surgical Options
Minimally Invasive Procedures
1- Rezūm (Water Vapor Therapy)
How it works: Uses steam to ablate excess prostate tissue.
Anesthesia: Local or light sedation; office-based.
Recovery: Temporary worsening of symptoms common for ~2 weeks; full improvement may take months[1].
Benefits: Generally preserves sexual function; low risk of erectile dysfunction.
Repeat Procedures: 7.5% at 5 years, up to 25% in larger, real-world studies.
Best for: Prostates <80g; data for larger prostates is still emerging.
2- UroLift
How it works: Places permanent implants to hold prostate tissue away from the urethra, similar to “curtain tiebacks.”
Anesthesia: Local or sedation.
Benefits: No significant issues with ejaculation or erectile function; immediate improvement for most.
Drawbacks: Up to 22% require retreatment in 5 years.
Best for: Prostates <80g; not ideal for certain prostate shapes (median lobe).
3- iTind
How it works: Temporary nitinol device reshapes the prostate, creating new channels for urine flow[1].
Duration: Device in place 5–7 days.
Benefits: Preserves sexual function, no permanent implant or tissue removal.
Drawbacks: Some discomfort while device is in; retreatment needed for 6–12% at 3 years.
Best for: Prostates 25–75g, without median lobe.
4- Optilume
How it works: Balloon dilation of prostate urethra, coated with chemotherapy agent (paclitaxel) to prevent tissue regrowth.
Benefits: Minimally invasive, promising early effectiveness.
Special caution: Use a condom for a month post-procedure; avoid conception for 6 months.
Data: Still emerging; early studies show 75–80% improvement at 1 year.
5- Prostate Artery Embolization
How it works: Interventional radiologists block blood flow to the prostate to shrink it over time.
Recovery: Quick, preserves sexual function.
Drawbacks: Less effective than surgery, especially in improving flow; retreatment rates up to 25% at 5 years[1].
Ideal for: Men with large prostates who are poor surgical candidates.
6- Aquablation
How it works: Robotic hydro-jet removes prostate tissue, guided by ultrasound.
Benefits: Works on prostates of any size, including those with complicated anatomy.
Risks: 19% risk of retrograde ejaculation; low transfusion/intervention rates; 4% retreatment at 4 years.
Drawbacks: Requires anesthesia and specialized facility.
Traditional Surgical Procedures
1- TURP (Transurethral Resection of the Prostate)
"Gold standard" for BPH surgery.
How it works: Electrified wire loop removes tissue via urethra.
Anesthesia: General or spinal.
Benefits: Extensive long-term data; very effective and durable (≤10% retreatment at 10+ years).
Risks: 6% blood transfusion rate, nearly universal retrograde ejaculation, potential need for short-term catheter[1].
2- Laser Procedures
Types: Photovaporization ("GreenLight"), HoLEP (Holmium Enucleation), ThuLEP (Thulium Enucleation)[1].
Benefits: Safe for men on blood thinners; rapid symptom relief.
Durability: 4–7% retreatment rate at 5–10 years (lowest for HoLEP/ThuLEP).
Risks: May cause irritative symptoms during recovery; 6–8% transient incontinence risk with enucleation; almost universal retrograde ejaculation.
3- Robotic Simple Prostatectomy
Indications: Very large prostates (>100g), or when treating bladder stones/diverticulum simultaneously.
How it works: Laparoscopic removal of prostate tissue through small abdominal incisions.
Benefits: Effective for large glands; low blood loss.
Drawbacks: More invasive; longer recovery (2–3 weeks for light activity), universal retrograde ejaculation[1].
Choosing the Right Procedure
There is no one-size-fits-all solution:
If ejaculation preservation is important: Prioritize UroLift, Rezūm, iTind, or Optilume.
If minimizing anesthesia and downtime is critical: Minimally invasive options are preferred.
If you need a durable, one-time solution (especially with large prostates): Traditional options like TURP, HoLEP, or robotic prostatectomy are best[1].
Medical comorbidities (e.g., inability to stop blood thinners): Favors minimally invasive or laser options.
For complex anatomy (e.g., median lobe, very large size): Some procedures may not be suitable; see an experienced urologist for evaluation.
Final Advice
Discuss your goals with your urologist: symptom priorities, recovery time, risks you’re willing to accept, and sexual side effect concerns. Ensure your chosen surgeon is experienced with the procedure you are considering, as high operator volume correlates with better outcomes and fewer complications[1].
With so many options available, personalized care is more important than ever. Take time to choose the path that aligns with your health needs and lifestyle priorities[1].
FAQs
1. What is Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH) and who does it affect?
Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia (BPH), commonly known as an enlarged prostate, is a condition that affects millions of men worldwide, particularly as they age. Approximately half of all men over 60 experience BPH, with the prevalence increasing significantly with each subsequent decade. BPH often leads to bothersome urinary symptoms such as urgency, frequent urination, dribbling, and incomplete bladder emptying, which can significantly reduce a man's quality of life.2. When is surgery for BPH typically considered?
Surgery for BPH is considered when lifestyle changes and medications are no longer effective or tolerable for the patient. It also becomes a necessary consideration in cases of "absolute indications," which include recurrent urinary tract infections, persistent bleeding from the prostate, kidney problems caused by urine backup, or the inability to urinate without a catheter.3. What key factors should be considered when choosing a BPH surgical procedure?
Several personal and medical factors influence the choice of BPH surgery. These include the size and anatomy of the prostate, the patient's overall health and ability to tolerate anesthesia, current medication use (especially blood thinners), the importance of preserving sexual function (particularly ejaculation), and the patient's tolerance for recovery time and the risk of needing repeat procedures.4. What are some minimally invasive surgical options for BPH and their general characteristics?
Minimally invasive procedures for BPH aim to reduce recovery time and impact on sexual function. Examples include:- Rezūm (Water Vapor Therapy): Uses steam to ablate prostate tissue, generally preserves sexual function, and is office-based. Recovery involves temporary symptom worsening.
- UroLift: Places permanent implants to hold prostate tissue away from the urethra, with immediate improvement and no significant issues with ejaculation.
- iTind: A temporary nitinol device that reshapes the prostate to create new urine flow channels, preserving sexual function without permanent implants.
- Optilume: Involves balloon dilation of the prostate urethra with a chemotherapy agent to prevent tissue regrowth.
- Prostate Artery Embolization: An interventional radiology procedure that blocks blood flow to shrink the prostate, preserving sexual function but generally less effective than surgery.
- Aquablation: A robotic hydro-jet procedure that removes prostate tissue guided by ultrasound, effective for prostates of any size.
5. What are some traditional surgical options for BPH and their general characteristics?
Traditional surgical procedures for BPH are generally more invasive but offer greater durability and efficacy, especially for larger prostates. These include:- TURP (Transurethral Resection of the Prostate): Considered the "gold standard," it uses an electrified wire loop to remove tissue. It is highly effective and durable but carries risks like retrograde ejaculation and potential need for blood transfusion.
- Laser Procedures: Such as Photovaporization ("GreenLight"), HoLEP (Holmium Enucleation), and ThuLEP (Thulium Enucleation). These are safer for men on blood thinners and offer rapid symptom relief, with HoLEP/ThuLEP being very durable. They also commonly cause retrograde ejaculation.
- Robotic Simple Prostatectomy: Used for very large prostates (>100g) or when treating other bladder issues simultaneously. It involves laparoscopic removal of prostate tissue and is effective with low blood loss, but is more invasive with a longer recovery and universal retrograde ejaculation.
6. Which BPH surgical options are best for preserving ejaculation and minimizing downtime?
For men who prioritize the preservation of ejaculation, minimally invasive options like UroLift, Rezūm, iTind, and Optilume are generally preferred. If minimizing anesthesia and downtime is a critical factor, these minimally invasive options are also the better choice.7. Which BPH surgical options are recommended for a durable, one-time solution, especially for large prostates?
When a durable, long-term solution is desired, especially for men with large prostates, traditional surgical options are often recommended. These include TURP, HoLEP (Holmium Enucleation), and robotic prostatectomy, as they offer lower retreatment rates and significant efficacy for larger glands.8. What is the final advice for a patient considering BPH surgery?
It is crucial for patients to have an in-depth discussion with their urologist about their personal goals, including symptom priorities, desired recovery time, acceptable risks, and concerns about sexual side effects. Given the wide range of available options, personalized care is essential. Patients should also ensure that their chosen surgeon has significant experience with the specific procedure being considered, as high operator volume correlates with better outcomes and fewer complications.SUMMARY PODCAST:
Last edited by a moderator:
