ExcelMale Consensus: Secondary hypogonadism is low testosterone caused by a weak signal from the hypothalamus or pituitary. The testes can still work, but LH and FSH are low or only "normal" when they should be high. In the European Male Ageing Study of 3,369 men, 11.8% had secondary hypogonadism and 2.0% had primary. Obesity was the strongest risk factor, and many cases improve when the cause is treated.
Key Takeaways
- Low testosterone with low or normal LH points to secondary hypogonadism. Low testosterone with high LH points to primary.
- Up to 85% of late-onset hypogonadism is functional, meaning no structural damage is found.
- Obesity, type 2 diabetes, opioids and past anabolic steroid use are the common reversible causes.
- Prolactin and iron studies belong in every workup. A pituitary MRI is reserved for specific findings.
- Men who want children can raise testosterone with Clomid, enclomiphene or hCG instead of TRT.
This thread began in 2019 when a member, Aki, asked why his LH and FSH sat below range with two normal pituitary MRIs and a total testosterone near 250 ng/dL. The late Dr. John Crisler couldn't give him a cause. His question is still below, along with the discussion it started on the ExcelMale forum. This summary collects what the research says.
How Is Secondary Hypogonadism Different From Primary Hypogonadism?
Secondary hypogonadism starts in the brain, and primary hypogonadism starts in the testes. LH tells them apart. In primary hypogonadism the pituitary sends a loud signal that failing testes can't answer, so LH runs high. In secondary hypogonadism the signal itself is weak.
| Secondary | Primary | Compensated | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Testosterone | Low | Low | Normal |
| LH | Low or normal | High | High |
| Where the problem sits | Hypothalamus or pituitary | Testes | Testes, early stage |
| Prevalence in men 40 to 79 (EMAS) | 11.8% | 2.0% | 9.5% |
| Main association (EMAS) | Obesity | Age | Age |
| Responds to Clomid or hCG | Usually | Poorly | Not needed |
Prevalence figures come from the European Male Ageing Study (Tajar 2010). Some texts split off "tertiary" hypogonadism for hypothalamic causes. In practice both are grouped as secondary because the lab pattern and the treatment are the same.
What Causes Secondary Hypogonadism?
Secondary hypogonadism has two groups of causes: functional ones that suppress a healthy pituitary, and structural ones that damage it. Functional causes are far more common. A 2018 review estimated that up to 85% of late-onset hypogonadism is functional, mostly tied to metabolic conditions (Rastrelli 2018).
Which causes are functional and potentially reversible?
Obesity leads the list. Men with a BMI of 30 or higher were 8.7 times as likely to have secondary hypogonadism in EMAS. Other functional causes:- Type 2 diabetes. In one study of 103 men with type 2 diabetes, 33% were hypogonadal with low LH and FSH (Dhindsa 2004).
- Opioids. A 2020 meta-analysis found hypogonadism in 63% of male long-term opioid users (de Vries 2020).
- Past or current use of anabolic steroids or testosterone, which shuts down LH and FSH.
- Long-term glucocorticoids.
- Untreated sleep apnea.
- Heavy alcohol use.
- Severe calorie restriction or overtraining.
- Serious chronic illness.
Which causes are structural?
Structural causes involve physical damage to the pituitary or hypothalamus. They include prolactin-secreting and other pituitary tumors, iron overload from hemochromatosis, head injury, radiation or surgery near the pituitary, and congenital conditions such as Kallmann syndrome.Head injury is underdiagnosed. Hypopituitarism was found in 15% to 50% of traumatic brain injury patients in most studies, and it persists in about 12% when testing is repeated (Tanriverdi 2015). The same review describes pituitary dysfunction in boxers and kickboxers. A member in this thread traced his own decline to a string of concussions from high school contact sports.
Which Lab Tests Confirm Secondary Hypogonadism?
Two fasting morning total testosterone tests plus LH and FSH confirm the diagnosis. The Endocrine Society guideline calls for a repeat test because a single low result often normalizes (Bhasin 2018).
Once LH comes back low or normal, the guideline recommends looking for the cause. That means serum prolactin and iron saturation at a minimum. Free testosterone matters when total is borderline or when SHBG is likely to be off, which is common in obesity and diabetes. Draw blood before starting any testosterone, Clomid or hCG. All three change LH.
When Do You Need a Pituitary MRI?
A pituitary MRI is recommended when total testosterone is below 150 ng/dL, when prolactin stays elevated, when other pituitary hormones are also low, or when you have symptoms of a mass such as new headaches or loss of side vision. These criteria come from the 2018 Endocrine Society guideline.
Most men with secondary hypogonadism don't meet them and have normal scans. Aki had two normal MRIs years apart. A normal MRI rules out a tumor. It does not rule out a functional cause.
Can Secondary Hypogonadism Be Reversed?
Functional secondary hypogonadism often improves when the cause is removed. Weight loss has the best data. In a meta-analysis of 24 studies, a low-calorie diet raised total testosterone by 2.87 nmol/L (about 83 ng/dL) and bariatric surgery raised it by 8.73 nmol/L (about 250 ng/dL). The amount of weight lost was the best predictor of the rise (Corona 2013).
Tapering opioids, treating sleep apnea and stopping an offending drug can do the same. Grossmann and Matsumoto recommend trying these steps first or alongside testosterone, and they are candid that lifestyle changes are hard to sustain and may fall short (Grossmann 2017). Structural causes rarely reverse.
How Is Secondary Hypogonadism Treated?
Treatment depends on whether you want children. Men who do can use drugs that raise the body's own LH or replace it. Men who don't usually choose testosterone replacement.
Clomid and enclomiphene block estrogen feedback at the pituitary. In phase III trials, enclomiphene restored normal testosterone in men with secondary hypogonadism and kept sperm counts in the normal range, while testosterone gel lowered them (Kim 2016). Our Clomid for men guide covers doses and side effects. hCG acts like LH directly on the testes, and the hCG, Clomid and Fertility index links the main threads.
Testosterone replacement works regardless of cause and has the most outcome data. It suppresses sperm production, so the Endocrine Society advises against it for men planning fertility soon.
What If No Cause Is Found?
Some men have clear secondary hypogonadism and a clean workup. Medicine calls this idiopathic, which means the cause is unknown. That was Aki's situation, and it is common on this forum.
The thread explored environmental estrogens as one explanation. Cataceous, a super moderator, summed up the evidence fairly: the science does not yet show that typical exposures are high enough to cause hypogonadism, and it doesn't rule it out either. We don't have good human data on this yet.
Members also noted a practical problem with Clomid in this group. Aki's total testosterone rose to 500 to 600 ng/dL on 12.5 mg per day. Another member, Gman86, went from about 600 to 1,500 ng/dL, but his SHBG climbed from 50 to 90 nmol/L and his free testosterone barely moved. Cataceous pointed to higher estradiol acting on the liver as the likely driver.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most common cause of secondary hypogonadism?
Obesity. In the European Male Ageing Study, a BMI of 30 or higher carried 8.7 times the risk of secondary hypogonadism.Is secondary hypogonadism permanent?
Not always. Functional cases linked to weight, medications or illness can improve when the cause is treated. Cases caused by pituitary damage usually need lifelong treatment.What LH level indicates secondary hypogonadism?
There is no single cutoff. An LH that is low or in the normal range alongside a clearly low testosterone indicates secondary hypogonadism, because a healthy pituitary would raise LH in response.Can Clomid treat secondary hypogonadism?
Yes, off-label. Clomid raises LH and FSH and works best when baseline LH is in the lower normal range. It does not help when the testes themselves have failed.Does secondary hypogonadism cause infertility?
It can, because low FSH and LH reduce sperm production. It is also the most treatable form of male infertility, since the testes respond once the signal is restored.Related ExcelMale Forum Discussions
- Primary or Secondary Hypogonadism. A member works through his labs to tell the two apart.
- Secondary Hypogonadism: Data on the Causes and Prevalence of Pituitary Lesions. How often MRIs find something.
- Does HCG Worsen Secondary Hypogonadism During a Restart?. hCG and pituitary feedback.
- Clomid for Men. Dosing, timelines and the enclomiphene comparison.
Key References
- Tajar A, et al. Characteristics of secondary, primary, and compensated hypogonadism in aging men: evidence from the European Male Ageing Study. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2010;95(4):1810-1818. doi:10.1210/jc.2009-1796
- Bhasin S, et al. Testosterone Therapy in Men With Hypogonadism: An Endocrine Society Clinical Practice Guideline. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2018;103(5):1715-1744. doi:10.1210/jc.2018-00229
- Rastrelli G, Maggi M, Corona G. Pharmacological management of late-onset hypogonadism. Expert Rev Clin Pharmacol. 2018;11(4):439-458. doi:10.1080/17512433.2018.1445969
- Grossmann M, Matsumoto AM. A Perspective on Middle-Aged and Older Men With Functional Hypogonadism: Focus on Holistic Management. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2017;102(3):1067-1075. doi:10.1210/jc.2016-3580
- Corona G, et al. Body weight loss reverts obesity-associated hypogonadotropic hypogonadism: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Eur J Endocrinol. 2013;168(6):829-843. doi:10.1530/EJE-12-0955
- de Vries F, et al. Opioids and Their Endocrine Effects: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2020;105(3):1020-1029. doi:10.1210/clinem/dgz022
- Dhindsa S, et al. Frequent occurrence of hypogonadotropic hypogonadism in type 2 diabetes. J Clin Endocrinol Metab. 2004;89(11):5462-5468. doi:10.1210/jc.2004-0804
- Tanriverdi F, et al. Pituitary dysfunction after traumatic brain injury: a clinical and pathophysiological approach. Endocr Rev. 2015;36(3):305-342. doi:10.1210/er.2014-1065
- Kim ED, et al. Oral enclomiphene citrate raises testosterone and preserves sperm counts in obese hypogonadal men, unlike topical testosterone. BJU Int. 2016;117(4):677-685. doi:10.1111/bju.13337
A Detail Worth Checking in Your Own History
Look at when your symptoms started, and what else changed that year. A new prescription, a 30-pound gain, a hard hit to the head, a stretch of night shifts. Doctors rarely ask, and the answer often points to the cause faster than another blood draw. If the timeline leads nowhere, the pituitary lesion data thread and the Clomid guide are the next two reads.
Medical Disclaimer: This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult a qualified healthcare provider before starting or modifying any hormone therapy or medical treatment.
Summary by Nelson Vergel | B.S. Chemical Engineering, MBA | Founder, ExcelMale.com | 34+ years on TRT | NIH and FDA advisory panel service | Author: Testosterone: A Man's Guide, Beyond Testosterone, The hCG Advantage, and From Pills to Implants. Updated November 2026.
About ExcelMale: ExcelMale.com is a men's health community founded by Nelson Vergel, with more than 24,000 members and over 20 years of archives covering testosterone replacement, hormone optimization, fertility, and men's sexual health.
Original Question From Member Aki (February 2019)
I realise I'm asking a very big question, but it seems (barring a pituitary tumor or head trauma) doctors don't seem to have any explanation for late occuring secondary hypogonadism. I even asked the late Dr. Crisler on the phone once, and he couldn't offer any suggestion.
Some salient facts from my life (for anyone interested in suggesting an explanation):
- I hit puberty with a bang (earlier than the average age, I would say) and I have normal secondary sexual characteristics.
- I have had MRIs (pituatary sella with contrast) done twice, both having normal results; one was done a few years ago and the second one around 2 month ago.
- I can't pinpoint the exact age at which I felt decline attributable to low-T; but it can't have been later than my mid-twenties because that was when I experienced symptoms such as depression and poor recovery from exercise. I wouldn't have said it was anything sudden, but there is one event that I can retrospectively identify, except I don't know if it has any bearing on my hormone issues at all:
- At age 19 (about 20 years ago), I suddenly experienced a massive amount of diffuse hair loss (on my head) - within the span of 3-4 months or so. Now, the thing is, male pattern baldness doesn't seem to run in either side of my family, based on the "visible evidence". And throughout the following 20 years my hair density kept fluctuating; sometimes getting thicker and other times thinner, even though I take no medication for it, which is also unlike male pattern baldness. And after a fews months of taking clomid the first time, my DHT was in the upper end of the range, yet I did not experience any more hair fall than usual. Right now the thinness is not even that obvious to the casual onlooker; and I guess it might be due to poor hormone balance rather than male pattern baldness. And now I wonder if that sudden loss of hair about 20 years ago was indicative of sudden hormonal changes of some sort..
- The first time I had my T levels measured (out of my own initiative) was around 9 years ago (at age 30), I measured around 250 ng/dL. I've never had a "natural" reading more 280, except when on clomid. And after giving up clomid recently it fell to around ~180 ng/dL.
- I know I'm secondary because my LH/FSH (without SERMs) tends to be below the bottom of the range.
- I don't know if I'm also partially primary but 12.5 mg clomid/day does raise my T levels to 500-600. (Note that I started taking clomid well into my thirties).
So, does anyone have any suggestions of other issues worth examining that might be causing secondary hypogonadism? Or should I just assume the state of endocrinology isn't that far advanced to have good answers to this question?
Last edited by a moderator: