madman
Super Moderator
Global consensus statement on testosterone therapy for women: an Australian perspective
Christina Jang, Jacqueline A Boyle, Amanda Vincent
There is more to female sexual function than circulating testosterone, and symptomatic women require a thorough clinical evaluation
The 2019 global consensus position statement on the use of testosterone therapy for women1 aims to provide guidance for clinicians managing women with female sexual dysfunction. The recommendations, graded according to levels of evidence, have been developed by an international task force with representatives from a range of organizations and societies, headed by Australian endocrinologist Professor Susan Davis, the current President of the International Menopause Society. The position statement bases many of its recommendations on a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.2
The meta-analysis includes data from 36 randomized controlled trials with 8480 participants and includes studies with a testosterone treatment duration of at least 12 weeks. The primary outcome indicates an improvement in satisfying sexual events, measured as a mean increase of one event over 4 weeks with the use of testosterone. There were also improvements in other parameters associated with sexual function, including sexual desire, arousal, and self-image. There were no cognitive, psychological, well-being, or musculoskeletal (including bone mineral density) benefits. In doses that approximate physiological levels, the main adverse effects of testosterone therapy are significant increases in acne and hair growth but no difference in alopecia, clitoromegaly, or voice change.
The position statement provides recommendations covering the assessment of women with female sexual dysfunction, laboratory measurement of testosterone, indications for treatment, and ongoing monitoring once treatment is commenced. It emphasizes that the only evidence-based indication for the use of testosterone in women is the treatment of postmenopausal women who have been diagnosed with hypoactive sexual dysfunction disorder (HSDD) after formal biopsychosocial assessment. Doses that approximate physiological testosterone concentrations in pre-menopausal women are recommended. At these doses, testosterone therapy is not associated with serious adverse events. Notably, there are no safety data for beyond 24 months of treatment. There are insufficient data regarding the use of testosterone therapy in pre-menopausal women. The position statement does not comment regarding women with premature ovarian insufficiency and recommends caution in women with a breast cancer diagnosis, reflecting the lack of data.3,4
The classification of female sexual disorders has been a source of controversy and debate. In the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Health Disorders, 5th Edition, HSDD, and female sexual arousal disorder (FSAD) have been amalgamated and classified as a single entity: female sexual interest/arousal disorder. The writing group for the position statement regards HSDD and FSAD to be distinct conditions, a view shared by experts in the field.5,6 Diagnostic criteria for both conditions are outlined in Box 1. 7 It is important to understand this clinical distinction as the position statement does not consider FSAD to be an indication for testosterone therapy.
The position statement does not comment on whether menopausal hormone therapy should be used concurrently with testosterone therapy. However, a biopsychosocial model of treatment of female sexual dysfunction is recommended, which may include menopausal hormone therapy. Multiple studies have looked at the effect of oestrogen therapy alone, testosterone alone and a combination of the two on female sexual function, with variable outcomes. One of the main criticisms of studies demonstrating no improvement with oestrogen (alone or combined with testosterone) is that low therapeutic doses of oestrogen were used and circulating oestradiol levels were either not measured or were low and did not reach pre-ovulatory levels consistent with those seen in pre-menopausal women.11 Only one of eight studies included in the meta-analysis did not include concomitant menopausal hormone therapy.2 Systemic oestrogen therapy is known to improve hot flushes, urogenital symptoms and mood disturbance, while topical vaginal oestrogen is effective in managing vulvovaginal atrophy.12 Both improve wellbeing in menopausal women and may enhance libido such that other therapies are not required,13 although an improvement in absolute terms has not been described. Our view is that menopausal hormone therapy with oestrogen with or without progestogen should be considered initially in all postmenopausal women who present with low libido before the initiation of testosterone.
Australian perspective
Sexual dysfunction is common among Australian women. The prevalence of low sexual desire and HSDD was 69.3% and 32.2%, respectively, among a sample of community-based women aged 40–65 years in one study.14 In older women, the prevalence of HSDD was reported to be one in seven women in a population of women aged 65–79 years living in the community.15
The use of testosterone for therapeutic purposes in women has been controversial. Despite this, clinicians in many countries including Australia have been prescribing testosterone off-label primarily for low sexual desire in women for several years.16 Various formulations have been used, including subcutaneous pellets, transdermal gels, and intramuscular injections that are designed for men, with dosing then adjusted for the female population. In this setting, there is greater potential for treatment to result in supraphysiological testosterone levels. The position statement suggests that ‘‘where approved female preparations are unavailable, off-label prescribing of an approved male formulation is reasonable”.1 Bio-identical and compounded products are not recommended. In Australia, a 1% transdermal testosterone cream is available, designed specifically for women, and indicated for symptoms caused by testosterone deficiency. Although the product is unlicensed in Australia, it has been available on prescription from pharmacies within Western Australia since 1999 due to an exemption under section 6 of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth). Women prescribed this treatment in other states are required to access it by mail order along with a prescription from their clinician. It was submitted for Therapeutic Goods Administration evaluation and inclusion on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods as a registered product in 2019 for the proposed indication of treatment of hypoactive sexual desire dysfunction in postmenopausal women, and a response is expected by the end of 2020 (Michael Buckley, Medical Director, Lawley Pharmaceuticals, personal communications). Although limited by small sample sizes, pharmacokinetic and clinical studies of the recommended 5–10 mg daily dose of this cream demonstrated total and free testosterone levels within or above the pre-menopausal range.17–19 Its availability in Australia overcomes the need to consider male preparations or compounded and bio-identical products.
Conclusion
The position statement is a timely addition to the literature regarding testosterone therapy for women. What is clear is that there is more to female sexual function than circulating testosterone and that symptomatic women require a thorough clinical evaluation, assessing for other factors that may be contributing to their presentation. Testosterone therapy is a small piece of the puzzle in the management of female sexual dysfunction. This position statement provides clarification regarding the indication, adverse effects, and knowledge gaps. The availability in Australia of a transdermal testosterone preparation designed for women obviates the need to use male preparations, but further research regarding efficacy and safety is necessary. Future studies should address the safety of long term use of testosterone in women, particularly with respect to cardiovascular disease and breast cancer.
Christina Jang, Jacqueline A Boyle, Amanda Vincent
There is more to female sexual function than circulating testosterone, and symptomatic women require a thorough clinical evaluation
The 2019 global consensus position statement on the use of testosterone therapy for women1 aims to provide guidance for clinicians managing women with female sexual dysfunction. The recommendations, graded according to levels of evidence, have been developed by an international task force with representatives from a range of organizations and societies, headed by Australian endocrinologist Professor Susan Davis, the current President of the International Menopause Society. The position statement bases many of its recommendations on a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.2
The meta-analysis includes data from 36 randomized controlled trials with 8480 participants and includes studies with a testosterone treatment duration of at least 12 weeks. The primary outcome indicates an improvement in satisfying sexual events, measured as a mean increase of one event over 4 weeks with the use of testosterone. There were also improvements in other parameters associated with sexual function, including sexual desire, arousal, and self-image. There were no cognitive, psychological, well-being, or musculoskeletal (including bone mineral density) benefits. In doses that approximate physiological levels, the main adverse effects of testosterone therapy are significant increases in acne and hair growth but no difference in alopecia, clitoromegaly, or voice change.
The position statement provides recommendations covering the assessment of women with female sexual dysfunction, laboratory measurement of testosterone, indications for treatment, and ongoing monitoring once treatment is commenced. It emphasizes that the only evidence-based indication for the use of testosterone in women is the treatment of postmenopausal women who have been diagnosed with hypoactive sexual dysfunction disorder (HSDD) after formal biopsychosocial assessment. Doses that approximate physiological testosterone concentrations in pre-menopausal women are recommended. At these doses, testosterone therapy is not associated with serious adverse events. Notably, there are no safety data for beyond 24 months of treatment. There are insufficient data regarding the use of testosterone therapy in pre-menopausal women. The position statement does not comment regarding women with premature ovarian insufficiency and recommends caution in women with a breast cancer diagnosis, reflecting the lack of data.3,4
The classification of female sexual disorders has been a source of controversy and debate. In the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Health Disorders, 5th Edition, HSDD, and female sexual arousal disorder (FSAD) have been amalgamated and classified as a single entity: female sexual interest/arousal disorder. The writing group for the position statement regards HSDD and FSAD to be distinct conditions, a view shared by experts in the field.5,6 Diagnostic criteria for both conditions are outlined in Box 1. 7 It is important to understand this clinical distinction as the position statement does not consider FSAD to be an indication for testosterone therapy.
The position statement does not comment on whether menopausal hormone therapy should be used concurrently with testosterone therapy. However, a biopsychosocial model of treatment of female sexual dysfunction is recommended, which may include menopausal hormone therapy. Multiple studies have looked at the effect of oestrogen therapy alone, testosterone alone and a combination of the two on female sexual function, with variable outcomes. One of the main criticisms of studies demonstrating no improvement with oestrogen (alone or combined with testosterone) is that low therapeutic doses of oestrogen were used and circulating oestradiol levels were either not measured or were low and did not reach pre-ovulatory levels consistent with those seen in pre-menopausal women.11 Only one of eight studies included in the meta-analysis did not include concomitant menopausal hormone therapy.2 Systemic oestrogen therapy is known to improve hot flushes, urogenital symptoms and mood disturbance, while topical vaginal oestrogen is effective in managing vulvovaginal atrophy.12 Both improve wellbeing in menopausal women and may enhance libido such that other therapies are not required,13 although an improvement in absolute terms has not been described. Our view is that menopausal hormone therapy with oestrogen with or without progestogen should be considered initially in all postmenopausal women who present with low libido before the initiation of testosterone.
Australian perspective
Sexual dysfunction is common among Australian women. The prevalence of low sexual desire and HSDD was 69.3% and 32.2%, respectively, among a sample of community-based women aged 40–65 years in one study.14 In older women, the prevalence of HSDD was reported to be one in seven women in a population of women aged 65–79 years living in the community.15
The use of testosterone for therapeutic purposes in women has been controversial. Despite this, clinicians in many countries including Australia have been prescribing testosterone off-label primarily for low sexual desire in women for several years.16 Various formulations have been used, including subcutaneous pellets, transdermal gels, and intramuscular injections that are designed for men, with dosing then adjusted for the female population. In this setting, there is greater potential for treatment to result in supraphysiological testosterone levels. The position statement suggests that ‘‘where approved female preparations are unavailable, off-label prescribing of an approved male formulation is reasonable”.1 Bio-identical and compounded products are not recommended. In Australia, a 1% transdermal testosterone cream is available, designed specifically for women, and indicated for symptoms caused by testosterone deficiency. Although the product is unlicensed in Australia, it has been available on prescription from pharmacies within Western Australia since 1999 due to an exemption under section 6 of the Therapeutic Goods Act 1989 (Cth). Women prescribed this treatment in other states are required to access it by mail order along with a prescription from their clinician. It was submitted for Therapeutic Goods Administration evaluation and inclusion on the Australian Register of Therapeutic Goods as a registered product in 2019 for the proposed indication of treatment of hypoactive sexual desire dysfunction in postmenopausal women, and a response is expected by the end of 2020 (Michael Buckley, Medical Director, Lawley Pharmaceuticals, personal communications). Although limited by small sample sizes, pharmacokinetic and clinical studies of the recommended 5–10 mg daily dose of this cream demonstrated total and free testosterone levels within or above the pre-menopausal range.17–19 Its availability in Australia overcomes the need to consider male preparations or compounded and bio-identical products.
Conclusion
The position statement is a timely addition to the literature regarding testosterone therapy for women. What is clear is that there is more to female sexual function than circulating testosterone and that symptomatic women require a thorough clinical evaluation, assessing for other factors that may be contributing to their presentation. Testosterone therapy is a small piece of the puzzle in the management of female sexual dysfunction. This position statement provides clarification regarding the indication, adverse effects, and knowledge gaps. The availability in Australia of a transdermal testosterone preparation designed for women obviates the need to use male preparations, but further research regarding efficacy and safety is necessary. Future studies should address the safety of long term use of testosterone in women, particularly with respect to cardiovascular disease and breast cancer.
