madman
Super Moderator
Vascular Necrosis of the Upper Extremity After Self-Treatment for Peyronie’s Disease
David Yang, MD, Joshua Savage, PA-C, Tobias Köhler, MD, MPH, Sevann Helo, MD, Landon Trost, MD, and Matthew Ziegelmann, MD
ABSTRACT
Peyronie’s disease (PD) is associated with significant psychosocial distress, including anxiety, depression, and negative effects on interpersonal relationships. We report outcomes in a patient who researched an enzymatic supplement intended for oral administration for treatment of PD and subsequently self-injected it intravascularly. The enzyme, a combination of serrapeptase and nattokinase, resulted in vascular necrosis of the upper extremity. Despite attempts to salvage the limb, he ultimately required transhumeral amputation. Although extreme, this case illustrates the potential risks of nonfood and Drug Administration-approved therapies, the significant psychosocial impact that PD can have on patients’ emotional well-being, and the extent to which some may go to seek treatment.
INTRODUCTION
Peyronie’s disease (PD) is a fibrotic disorder involving the tunica albuginea of the penis. Although the physical aspects of the disease, including penile curvature, pain, shortening, and changes in sexual function, are well known to most providers, the significant impact that PD has on the psychosocial well-being of a patient and his partner may be overlooked.1,2 Men with PD commonly report emotional distress and relationship difficulties, including loss of sexual confidence, sexual performance anxiety, and social isolation as a result of their PD.2,3 Nelson et al4 demonstrated that nearly 50% of men with PD in their clinic met the definition for clinically meaningful depression that would warrant medical evaluation.
Although it is clear that PD significantly impacts patients’ emotional well-being, the extent to which a patient is willing to go to improve his symptoms is often unrecognized. Similarly, the combination of PD and pre-existing psychiatric disorders may lead to impaired judgment, increase higher risk behaviors, or reduce the ability to cope with adverse outcomes. Herein, we present one such example of a patient with a prior history of psychiatric conditions and high-risk behavior who attempted to self-treat his PD with disastrous consequences.
CASE REPORT (see PDF)
DISCUSSION
Although extreme, the current case highlights the significant psychological burden of PD and the extent to which high-risk patients may go to achieve a satisfactory treatment. Several authors have identified associations between PD and overall psychosexual and social well-being. Gelbard et al5 found that nearly 80% of patients reported negative psychological effects from PD, which persisted in more than half of the men. Several other studies identified low self-esteem, depression, and reduced quality of life with PD, suggesting a clear link between sexual well-being and overall health.1,2 Patients may feel socially stigmatized and isolated from their peers, which further exacerbates the detrimental psychosocial consequences of this disease process.2 These factors, combined with a prior history of depression and substance abuse, likely contributed to the poor decisionmaking in the case described.
Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict when a patient will take extraordinary attempts at self-treatment. Spending ample time with patients to explore their psychosocial burden is necessary along with discussing the rationale for using an evidence-based approach. While counseling patients with PD, we often focus on the proven therapies and gloss over unproven or debunked treatments as they are not a part of our treatment armamentarium. This patient had a history of high-risk behaviors and had already attempted self-treatment with topical vitamin E. In our experience, roughly 20% of our patients with PD have attempted previous treatment with various oral therapies before presentation to our clinic.6 With the increase in direct-to-consumer advertising and the rise of online men’s health clinics, counseling patients on the risks of unproven therapies may protect patients from physical and financial harm. As seen here, even over-the-counter treatments, when not properly used, can lead to serious and unforeseen consequences.
Serracor-NK (AST Enzymes) is an over-the-counter supplement that consists of enteric-coated serrapeptase and nattokinase in a capsule form. Serrapeptase (also known as serratiopeptidase) is a proteolytic enzyme, derived from the Serratia bacterium, with anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties.7 It is delivered enterally and has been studied in multiple surgical specialties. Several small trials from the orthopedic, otorhinolaryngology, and dentistry literature have suggested improvements in pain and inflammation for conditions such as carpal tunnel syndrome, arthritis, and molar extraction.7 Although reports detailing adverse effects with this agent are few, pneumonitis, joint aches, and dermatitis have all been reported with the oral preparation.7 Nattokinase, a protease with fibrinolytic activity, was derived from Bacillus subtilis.8 It is being investigated as an alternative to currently available thrombolytic agents and has been suggested to protect the brain in the setting of an ischemic insult.9 Interestingly, the 2 agents together have been studied in a rat model for Alzheimer’s disease.10
Although limited use of serrapeptase and nattokinase has been reported in other conditions, to date, no studies have evaluated its use for the treatment of PD. Despite this lack of evidence, an online search for “Serracor-NK and Peyronie’s disease” reveals multiple distributors claiming efficacy when used for the treatment of penile curvature and pain. The therapy has not been submitted to the Food and Drug Administration for review and has not previously undergone phase I trials to assess for safety. In addition, to our knowledge, neither serraptease nor nattokinase has been evaluated for clinical safety with intravenous or intraarterial administration in humans as was observed in the current case.
The case emphasizes the emotional toll that PD can take on patients and serves as a reminder to consider addressing the psychosocial consequences of the disease concurrently with physical changes. It is our current practice to refer patients to a therapist specializing in sexual health concerns based on clinician judgment and the patient’s reported level of distress. However, many patients are reticent to discuss their emotional hardships during their initial consultation, and there are likely many patients who would benefit from a collaborative model that integrates both cares of the disease itself and the psychological impact.1
David Yang, MD, Joshua Savage, PA-C, Tobias Köhler, MD, MPH, Sevann Helo, MD, Landon Trost, MD, and Matthew Ziegelmann, MD
ABSTRACT
Peyronie’s disease (PD) is associated with significant psychosocial distress, including anxiety, depression, and negative effects on interpersonal relationships. We report outcomes in a patient who researched an enzymatic supplement intended for oral administration for treatment of PD and subsequently self-injected it intravascularly. The enzyme, a combination of serrapeptase and nattokinase, resulted in vascular necrosis of the upper extremity. Despite attempts to salvage the limb, he ultimately required transhumeral amputation. Although extreme, this case illustrates the potential risks of nonfood and Drug Administration-approved therapies, the significant psychosocial impact that PD can have on patients’ emotional well-being, and the extent to which some may go to seek treatment.
INTRODUCTION
Peyronie’s disease (PD) is a fibrotic disorder involving the tunica albuginea of the penis. Although the physical aspects of the disease, including penile curvature, pain, shortening, and changes in sexual function, are well known to most providers, the significant impact that PD has on the psychosocial well-being of a patient and his partner may be overlooked.1,2 Men with PD commonly report emotional distress and relationship difficulties, including loss of sexual confidence, sexual performance anxiety, and social isolation as a result of their PD.2,3 Nelson et al4 demonstrated that nearly 50% of men with PD in their clinic met the definition for clinically meaningful depression that would warrant medical evaluation.
Although it is clear that PD significantly impacts patients’ emotional well-being, the extent to which a patient is willing to go to improve his symptoms is often unrecognized. Similarly, the combination of PD and pre-existing psychiatric disorders may lead to impaired judgment, increase higher risk behaviors, or reduce the ability to cope with adverse outcomes. Herein, we present one such example of a patient with a prior history of psychiatric conditions and high-risk behavior who attempted to self-treat his PD with disastrous consequences.
CASE REPORT (see PDF)
DISCUSSION
Although extreme, the current case highlights the significant psychological burden of PD and the extent to which high-risk patients may go to achieve a satisfactory treatment. Several authors have identified associations between PD and overall psychosexual and social well-being. Gelbard et al5 found that nearly 80% of patients reported negative psychological effects from PD, which persisted in more than half of the men. Several other studies identified low self-esteem, depression, and reduced quality of life with PD, suggesting a clear link between sexual well-being and overall health.1,2 Patients may feel socially stigmatized and isolated from their peers, which further exacerbates the detrimental psychosocial consequences of this disease process.2 These factors, combined with a prior history of depression and substance abuse, likely contributed to the poor decisionmaking in the case described.
Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict when a patient will take extraordinary attempts at self-treatment. Spending ample time with patients to explore their psychosocial burden is necessary along with discussing the rationale for using an evidence-based approach. While counseling patients with PD, we often focus on the proven therapies and gloss over unproven or debunked treatments as they are not a part of our treatment armamentarium. This patient had a history of high-risk behaviors and had already attempted self-treatment with topical vitamin E. In our experience, roughly 20% of our patients with PD have attempted previous treatment with various oral therapies before presentation to our clinic.6 With the increase in direct-to-consumer advertising and the rise of online men’s health clinics, counseling patients on the risks of unproven therapies may protect patients from physical and financial harm. As seen here, even over-the-counter treatments, when not properly used, can lead to serious and unforeseen consequences.
Serracor-NK (AST Enzymes) is an over-the-counter supplement that consists of enteric-coated serrapeptase and nattokinase in a capsule form. Serrapeptase (also known as serratiopeptidase) is a proteolytic enzyme, derived from the Serratia bacterium, with anti-inflammatory and analgesic properties.7 It is delivered enterally and has been studied in multiple surgical specialties. Several small trials from the orthopedic, otorhinolaryngology, and dentistry literature have suggested improvements in pain and inflammation for conditions such as carpal tunnel syndrome, arthritis, and molar extraction.7 Although reports detailing adverse effects with this agent are few, pneumonitis, joint aches, and dermatitis have all been reported with the oral preparation.7 Nattokinase, a protease with fibrinolytic activity, was derived from Bacillus subtilis.8 It is being investigated as an alternative to currently available thrombolytic agents and has been suggested to protect the brain in the setting of an ischemic insult.9 Interestingly, the 2 agents together have been studied in a rat model for Alzheimer’s disease.10
Although limited use of serrapeptase and nattokinase has been reported in other conditions, to date, no studies have evaluated its use for the treatment of PD. Despite this lack of evidence, an online search for “Serracor-NK and Peyronie’s disease” reveals multiple distributors claiming efficacy when used for the treatment of penile curvature and pain. The therapy has not been submitted to the Food and Drug Administration for review and has not previously undergone phase I trials to assess for safety. In addition, to our knowledge, neither serraptease nor nattokinase has been evaluated for clinical safety with intravenous or intraarterial administration in humans as was observed in the current case.
The case emphasizes the emotional toll that PD can take on patients and serves as a reminder to consider addressing the psychosocial consequences of the disease concurrently with physical changes. It is our current practice to refer patients to a therapist specializing in sexual health concerns based on clinician judgment and the patient’s reported level of distress. However, many patients are reticent to discuss their emotional hardships during their initial consultation, and there are likely many patients who would benefit from a collaborative model that integrates both cares of the disease itself and the psychological impact.1
