I think they all contribute some really good things to the field overall, but u unfortunately have to take certain things they all say with a grain of salt,
@readalot, lets go with @Gman86 here. Let's critically listen to everything these guys say, and use what's good (if any), discard what's bad. There may be some good in their works, doesn't mean we should not benefit from those things because of the other crap they speak. (I'm not throwing myself into the ring today though and giving examples).
I navigate steroid forums for information in this manner. You have to pick up data and anecdotes from everywhere. Look for patterns and commonalities, discard noise, check the science and then see what best "fits" your outcome.
Really, everything does not match up with science. For example, go look at people's experience's with NPP vs Deca. Nandrolone is just nandrolone right? Wrong. Totally different results. It can't be 99% of all those people are wrong.
Sometimes we figure things out anecdotally, and then the science will catch up one day.